HomeNews & PoliticsRelated VideosMore From: CBC News

Bridge collapses 6 hours after opening

220 ratings | 24743 views
An official in a Saskatchewan community where a bridge collapsed says a geotechnical study of a riverbed wasn't done before the structure was built in the rural municipality of Clayton. Reeve Duane Hicks initially told CBC the geotech work wasn't done because it's not possible to do that work under the river. To read more: https://www.cbc.ca/1.4829890 »»» Subscribe to CBC News to watch more videos: http://bit.ly/1RreYWS Connect with CBC News Online: For breaking news, video, audio and in-depth coverage: http://bit.ly/1Z0m6iX Find CBC News on Facebook: http://bit.ly/1WjG36m Follow CBC News on Twitter: http://bit.ly/1sA5P9H For breaking news on Twitter: http://bit.ly/1WjDyks Follow CBC News on Instagram: http://bit.ly/1Z0iE7O Download the CBC News app for iOS: http://apple.co/25mpsUz Download the CBC News app for Android: http://bit.ly/1XxuozZ »»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»» For more than 75 years, CBC News has been the source Canadians turn to, to keep them informed about their communities, their country and their world. Through regional and national programming on multiple platforms, including CBC Television, CBC News Network, CBC Radio, CBCNews.ca, mobile and on-demand, CBC News and its internationally recognized team of award-winning journalists deliver the breaking stories, the issues, the analyses and the personalities that matter to Canadians.
Category: News & Politics
Get embed code!
Text Comments (197)
Patriottoo2 (16 days ago)
Sometimes cheap doesn't pay off. Appears it was a balancing act with no means to tie the superstructure together.
Mi (21 days ago)
Hahaha. Canadian technology.
WANNA GET LUCKY (27 days ago)
POUND FOOLISH LOL HAHAHAHAHAHA
WANNA GET LUCKY (27 days ago)
BAAAAAAHAAAAAHAAAAA LOL HAHAHAHAHAHA
the Unrepentant (28 days ago)
*Piles sticking up in the soft riverbed.* Piles should have been driven down to refusal, then a supporting structure erected on top of the row of piles to hold up the bridge deck. This is _basic_ civil engineering.
Darryl Learie (28 days ago)
Someone needs to be fired ASAP
Freedom ForAll (28 days ago)
It wasnt an act of god...it was the lack of none geotechnical investigationl. 😂
BillHK (28 days ago)
I like how she saying "arm or Clayton" and "reeve of the arm". She needs some English lessons or to get another job.
Michael Zimmermann (28 days ago)
Lmao. Morons!!
Royal Caymanian (28 days ago)
The irony of this: some Chinese guy is watching this and mimicking Crocodile Dundee, “That’s not a bridge, this is a bridge!”, pointing to their new super duper highway bridge.😱
tgooding (28 days ago)
They FAILED! They screwed up and get a big F on their performance and decision making abilities.
David Morinville (28 days ago)
Just to show how much white people are becoming dumber and dumber evry 10 years. The gouvernment hire these dumb asses. Its not expensice to vuild anything except for time. And of course since white people dont know anything about the layout of Canada. My tribe were builders back 20000 years ago here in Kanada. But for some reasons or another white people think they are better in building crap that has to be repaired.and if the soil was the problem than help the soil to be stronger and not weaker . Actually ill keep that knowledge for my people and not tge gouvernment
cupguin (28 days ago)
Building somewhere that won't support a bridge is an act of God in the looses sense of the term. The ground conditions were "an act of god", not finding out what those conditions were was an act of negligence.
Mark Plain (28 days ago)
As a person who has been involved in the pricing of bridge design and construction, Geotech investigations are very expensive contrary to the statement at min 1:17. This Engineering Professor at UofT should stick to teaching and stay away from the profession. Geotech testing in this case, would generally require a barge with a large encapsulated drilling machinery to be brought into a remote area and assembled for drilling samples. Geotech investigations under these conditions could easily cost more than the entire bridge construction. . I can well imagine that the 2 engineering disciplines were done separately (bridge design and geotech investigation). Although Bridge Engineers generally refuse to do a bridge design without the Geotech investigation report on their desk. . The Bridge design team may well have prepared a generic design and handed it to the Reeve. The intention would be that the Reeve will have the construction contractor marry the design to the required pile foundations as per the geotech investigation. Reeve in turn may have tendered for Geotech investigations and found that the pricing was way over the top and outside any budget. He or she then decided to have the contractor do piling to a 'generic standard' under a presumption of the geological sub-terrain. That is a gamble. If you complete that bridge and then drive some heavy vehicles over the bridge (and it survives) then the gamble is looking good and the Reeve will have saved a ton of money (but it is still a gamble). If the bridge collapses (as it did) the gamble will not have paid off. . Is this an ideal way to build bridges? - no. But it is simply a more honest reasoning as to why this happened. CBC should do their homework and interview more people rather than some Professor who obviously doesn't have experience with the costing of engineering.
The Bearded Canucks (28 days ago)
Good choice on the engineer lol
B.B.V. Productions (28 days ago)
You can't fool anyone what's really going on here. Someone is clearly scheming.
Lok Tom (29 days ago)
Yes, lets play the BLAME GAME. The people in the office always win.
Ufo Trailers (29 days ago)
Bahahaha! Clearly non union! Bahahaha FOOLS I'm pissing my pants!
Smooth Operator (29 days ago)
Ah the old “act of God” trick,been working for years to fool individuals...Nowadays I’m noticing people are getting wiser.
t- milt (29 days ago)
Lol the only act of god was that nobody was driving on it at the time.
Christopher Guy (29 days ago)
Not an act of God but an act of engineering incompetence. Soil testing and understanding of geological conditions at the site are not an option they are mandatory for proper engineering calculations. The engineer was negligent in my opinion and should have their license revoked. The firm needs to be held accountable and the government officials overseeing the work should be fired. The only act of God was that no one was killed in this blunder.
OIFDV2010 (29 days ago)
It’s sad no CBC reporters were lost with this tragedy
Dirty Burger (29 days ago)
Just another example of a job done by the government that involves multiple parties that dont know what they ate doing.
Brandon Beavis Investing (29 days ago)
Ya dun goofed it!
Mag (29 days ago)
Act of God !!! Those funny Canadians. :)
jimmy matho (29 days ago)
Act of God hey is that the new term when the government blows our money
Otanaku Leana (29 days ago)
God: *Excuse me what the F**K?* **inserting image**
Gil T (29 days ago)
Really! Piles are to be driven to refusal. Pile driver was totally not the right size. Again there is someone in charge that is way over there heads. As a Inspector I have driven thousands of piles and never ever had any issues . I am not a engineer but I have in my 40yrs of experience sure have corrected a few engineers. When you pay peanuts for supervision you get monkeys.
Henry Townshed (29 days ago)
G looking at that one photo I wonder why that bridge collapsed I have no idea look at it structural support
Eusunt Dac (29 days ago)
Whoever build it better pay back the money they got paied, or pay for rebuilding it. Otherwise, taxpayers will be taken for fools.
Andrej Korenić (29 days ago)
Who's this muddy Rick Mercer?
Clarissa Lee (29 days ago)
They probably force a group of people to build a bridge just to say they can do just as good as boys, but better. Same thing like bridge in Miami that collapsed. Forced people who rwlaly have no business making bridges
JamesScottB (29 days ago)
This is ridiculous. I have designed buildings and one bridge and NONE of my projects have been conducted without a geotechnical study. This is a fraction of a percent of the total project cost and unbelievable this happened. The designers/constructors are lucky nobody was killed--they would be in prison for the rest of their lives.
Brad Pike (29 days ago)
This is infuriating... Sounds like an incompetent politician hired an incompetent contractor (most likely related or friends) and (most likely) both got away with tax payers money. They got away with it by blaming a fictitious character... which probably means no (competent) engineer was involved. Then in 4 to 6 weeks will receive another payment for rebuilding the bridge since it was "gods" fault and not the contractors. I think the community should get to the bottom of this and file criminal charges. I'm not sure of what illegal activity was involved but I guarantee you there was some form of "crookery" involved. If not get the contractor and the person who signed off on that permit for endangering human lives, criminal negligence and any other charges and fines. What if a school bus was the first vehicle to cross this? This stuff happens every day in Canada. We teach our children accountability why shouldn't we hold government officials to the same standard? Lock em up!
TheWolfsan (29 days ago)
The ecoterrorists probably sabotaged it.
Kevin Lau (29 days ago)
Canada is stuck in stone age.
Yola Montalvan (1 month ago)
So they will not be punished because nobody died? There is new bridge being built in Montreal South Shore, I hope the engineers are not from that company.
Christ Q (1 month ago)
If this is the "Act of God", the god is punishing whoever building this bridge is being too lazy to spend time to check the riverbed before they start the construction.
Derka Derka (1 month ago)
Toronto, Vancouver = lots of immigration = import of high skills = no colapsing bridges; Saskatchewan = mostly white people = colapsing bridge.
VTube zeeker (1 month ago)
It must be Chinese fault.
Lok Tom (29 days ago)
I think it was Diaper Trump farted.
Zdenek Niederle (1 month ago)
Likely built by people hired based on diversity rather than merit.
Zdenek Niederle (1 month ago)
Must have been designed by Canadian university graduates or new immigrant engineers.
James Australian (1 month ago)
All the pilings look in tact, none broke per say. So its a foundation issue. then again its why we should wait for a proper engineering team to investigate rather than the usual trial by media.
Tournel Henry (1 month ago)
Didn't know gods collapsed bridges too. Well, I guess they work in mysterious ways😂
Zeta Retikuli (1 month ago)
The mothman did it
Alex Tan (1 month ago)
Made in China tofu STRUCTURES?
Iowarail (1 month ago)
So wasting the taxpayers money in an Act of God????? Who's God???
Eric Von (1 month ago)
Im going to rob a bank tomorrow. Dont stop me or charge me because its an "act of god".
Lil Trash (1 month ago)
Somebody need to go back to engineering school
Johnny Dominguez (1 month ago)
Money meant for building and inspection got diverted to the "refugees..." most likely. Oh, and leave God out of this... He had nothing to do with it.
alan wisdom (1 month ago)
'Act of God' Rather an act of people who don't know how to work, hopefully no one died.
Johnny Dominguez (1 month ago)
Only the builder's reputation...
Tall Topp (1 month ago)
If God would've touched it, it would be still standing strong, Amen!
Mark Stevens (1 month ago)
Yes, “god” made the reeve and the contractor as dumb as posts. Doesn’t mean they shouldn’t be sued.
Ruddi Bruce getting the word out (1 month ago)
What crap in today’s age.
sanjaya Ekanayake (1 month ago)
"Act of God" .. what is this year 1418?
Marylee Macpherson (1 month ago)
Absolutely the company is to blame 👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽
tiffany hirst (1 month ago)
Shady asf
Jean Berube (1 month ago)
Just like CBC our tax dollars hard at work
Dezso Simon (1 month ago)
Engineering fail!
Kim McLellan (1 month ago)
Tudo designed it!!LOL
Whatever Idontcare (1 month ago)
Wow, don't blame God for this. This is human negligence and greed, pure and simple.
King Kashton (1 month ago)
Very costly? & it is very dangerous if someone drove a car or walked on it
R T (1 month ago)
Cwb welder or a person who had sneakers and a welding helmet
MrMaenambeach (1 month ago)
"An act of god"? Which one?
Raeda Masri (1 month ago)
Peoples lives are more "costly"
Niki L (1 month ago)
I hope the engineers have good e&o insurance. They should be sued.
Lok Tom (29 days ago)
Not when the government were under the bed sheets with them.
timmmahhhh (29 days ago)
If they do, they won't have it after this. No insurer in their right mind would associate with such incompetence
Chillmaster (1 month ago)
Lowest bidder.
campkira (1 month ago)
Insurance is the first come to mind.
Mathieu MacAdam (1 month ago)
Look at the center pillings - the cross braces have sunk several feet into the clearly soft ground. Not needing any geotechnical assessment my rear end.
JOHN ABRAHAM (1 month ago)
I AM 100 % SURE THAT BUILDER IS A LIBERAL 😁
It's OK to be white in Canada (1 month ago)
this is what diversity hires get you instead of hiring the best qualified people.
ctawab (1 month ago)
Omg I work for a geotechnical company It collapsed 6 hours after build and I am watching it 6 hours after uploading
111highgh (28 days ago)
+Lok Tom I spent last night stroking my brains out.
111highgh (28 days ago)
+Lok Tom I need a female to fart in my mouth.
Lok Tom (29 days ago)
I think the government must have skipped SUNDAY church going a long time ago.
111highgh (29 days ago)
+Johnny Dominguez I spent last night stroking my brains out.
111highgh (29 days ago)
+Johnny Dominguez I need a female to fart in my mouth.
grrdpablo1 (1 month ago)
Canadian Optimism, Bridge can be rebuilt in 3 -4 weeks. KaBoooom
Ricky Bobby (1 month ago)
How about 1 day? 6 deaths. Kaboom. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florida_International_University_pedestrian_bridge_collapse
45von (1 month ago)
First you have to be a gullible fool to believe there is anything like a god, then if you buy that BS you are ready for the 'act of god' part...
Johnny Dominguez (1 month ago)
Thanks for your 2 cents... hold on... here's your change...
tyranomegosaurus (1 month ago)
I work for a Geotechnical and Material testing company and that is so unacceptable not to getting that testing done!
jachtan crozomer (1 month ago)
Weak
sandor szabados (1 month ago)
Earthquake? Volcano? Tornado? Hurricane? Flash flood?.....
Johnny Dominguez (1 month ago)
NO! It was the calm and clear day that caused this! 🤔😑
4G12 (1 month ago)
Bean counter engineering, Hurrah!
NPC #775968657554 (1 month ago)
Looks like Canadian engineering
Ricky Bobby (1 month ago)
Six deaths, up one day...might want to look in your own backyard, genius. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florida_International_University_pedestrian_bridge_collapse
Much Doge Very Wow (1 month ago)
Lol they did a bad job
Nia Pgn (1 month ago)
More costly than human lives? Wth. They all need to be charged.
Rollling (29 days ago)
You mean heads should be chopped ?
Joe Al (29 days ago)
Hi dear ⚘
Max Zomboni (1 month ago)
It's lucky that nobody was killed as a result of this incompetence.
Dear Mr. _-isaiah- deringer;_ (1 month ago)
*Fire was once considered an Act of God!* *Scientist.* I recommend to use them.
STUBS 1960 (1 month ago)
Canadian engineering. 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Ricky Bobby (1 month ago)
Another genius here. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Florida_International_University_pedestrian_bridge_collapse
deliman7203 (1 month ago)
Where did they get the design from... the 60's. 3 to 4 weeks to take down and replace... who's doing the work.. god? Oh they must be using prefab bridge sections.
puirYorick (1 month ago)
"Act of god" makes rural Canada sound like America's deep South. Replacing sound engineering and science with an 'aw shucks' religious blind faith. Now the taxpayers are stuck clearing up the mess. The reeve should resign and the contractor should lose their accreditation to build any commercial or public projects. If he wants to skimp on engineering let it be on his own private hut.
IveGotWheels (29 days ago)
timmmahhhh, thanks! I too am cynical about religion, or any dogmatic practices for that matter. Trouble is these days, people are so caught up in resisting a specific set of dogmas that they don’t realize how dogmatic they’ve become to rationalize their own opposition.
timmmahhhh (29 days ago)
+IveGotWheels While my cynicism for religion aligns with the OP, you have an excellent point regarding the Act of God clause.
IveGotWheels (1 month ago)
I am speculating of course, but I don’t believe the spokesperson meant act of God in the literal sense, but in the way that insurance agencies use the term. It’s certainly antiquated by today’s standards but it essentially means that it is the result of a natural disaster; ie. flood, tornado, etc.. That being said, this was decidedly not an act of God as the collapse was caused by gross negligence via omission of the proper surveys as opposed to some unforeseen disaster. To say that the spokesperson literally believes God came down and destroyed his new bridge is to be intentionally ignorant for the purpose of your own personal outrage. Well hey, we’re on CBC so that’s normal here right?
Trailerguy (1 month ago)
*Curb your enthusiasm theme*
TK Baha (1 month ago)
kickbacks, corruption, bribery.
oabuseer (1 month ago)
God is always blamed for good things, I don't see what's wrong with blaming him for a bad thing :)
Whatever Idontcare (1 month ago)
When was the last time you actually thanked God for a good thing that happened to you? People are always thinking that they are the only one in the right.
Ashley Y (1 month ago)
People in rural communities are so bigoted they can't change a lightbulb let alone build a bridge.
Travis Ramage (1 month ago)
You sound like a bigot.
SuTen (1 month ago)
just convert it to a boat ramp.....
Lok Tom (29 days ago)
More like a delinquent's skate board ram.
TyroneBiggums (1 month ago)
hehe Dont know whats Funnier, the bridge or CBC news Vagaina!! aaahhhhh,
TyroneBiggums (29 days ago)
Virtuitous Vampire I know, god im such a looser, good bye world, I tride.
Virtuitous Vampire (29 days ago)
TyroneBiggums obviously you don’t know how to use “swoosh” either.
TyroneBiggums (1 month ago)
Swooosh!! lol to easy!!
Mark Stevens (1 month ago)
TyroneBiggums hard to believe you survived on that intellect long enough to acquire computing skills or even rudimentary language. Right out of fourth grade.
spiffcats (1 month ago)
What can I say, humans are getting dumber, and build a bridge is a complex job.
matt taylor (1 month ago)
the general contractor is responsible for this kind of thing
tim m (1 month ago)
There's never time to do it right, but there's always time to do it over. Should of have got Holmes to do it.
June Hass (1 month ago)
China?
Sebastie Cortes (1 month ago)
"act of God" sounds more like corruption and taxpayers mismanagement.
Kys cunts (28 days ago)
Ash Roskell Are you good? This was in canada.
Ash Roskell (28 days ago)
Sebastie Cortes : This is Trump’s promised, “Best infrastructure in the world,” right . . . SMH
Lok Tom (29 days ago)
Yes, play the BLAME GAME. Screw the tax payers. More $ goes to the Paradise Paper Elites Scheme Bank Accounts.
Cyber Scout (29 days ago)
I agrre
200 iq rick and morty fan (1 month ago)
It was an act of allah
Johnny Dominguez (1 month ago)
So it was blown up?? 💣💥💢🕳
Purr Cat (1 month ago)
God must live inside the bureaucracy that tossed the contract to the builder.
hogensan (1 month ago)
The rise of incompetence continues in all government.