Who's Winning the Shipping War? - Evaluating UPS, FedEx and USPS for package tracking, delivery time and shipping costs.
This video highlights a real-world study comparing the top three U.S. shipping carriers on tracking scans, delivery time and overall shipping costs.
Download the free white paper: http://www.stamps.com/shippingwar/form/
USPS hasn't failed me yet with delivery times and cost. UPS takes too long if you want the cheapest option. and FedEx is in the middle, a bit faster when you get the cheapest option than UPS. this is all in my online seller experience.
Richard Blanchard (9 days ago)
Mr. Veritas (1 month ago)
This is bull crap. I've had the best experience with UPS hands down.
respinoza89 (2 months ago)
What about items over 5 pounds
Geeky gamer (3 months ago)
FEDEX is so unreliable
Mikgwerd (1 year ago)
Face it. All three can suck in their own unique ways. USPS wins for me(barely)...unlike the other two, they actually called me back to issue an apology for misplacing and delaying an express mail package!
jma111000 (1 year ago)
I can't believe that Fedex won battle 3.
They barely update my delivery at all!
I tend to love USPS and have barely used the others, but favor UPS over Fedex generally.
Ritchie R (1 year ago)
I don't see how they can talk so good about USPS they are always delaying my packages 5-10 days. I live close to houston and the scan is always in houston then days later after its delivered it will post delivered. Why do you think amazon wants to use air prime cause they are tired of putting up with USPS.
Rick Alex (1 year ago)
+non yobussiness I read recently that UPS was having trouble getting seasonal employees for the holidays. Maybe they have alot of full time.
non yobussiness (1 year ago)
I know for UPS they have a shortage of workers. no one is applying. it might be the same for all three. if you know someone that needs a job and is willing to stay around, that might be a good career for them.
Jason Camacho (1 year ago)
Aaron L. (1 year ago)
I call bullshit. USPS destroys or loses a good 30% of the packages I get through them and I am currently holding a package from them that their "tracking" still says is in Kentucky... I live in Michigan.
They are fast and that is about it. I would rather wait an extra day to actual get my packages intact. Half the time I have to hunt my packages down at the local post office.
Theft Tv (1 year ago)
for me its UPS who destroys my shit! USPS rocks where I live, don't know how well fedex is though
FGOKURULES (1 year ago)
SOOOOOO. let me let you all in on a SECRET that this video doesn't share. You ever wonder why you don't see any planes with USPS on them? guess who sorts all of the mail being flown around? yep you guessed it UPS/FEDEX both have contracts to sort and fly the USPS mail to the local post offices. So why does it get there faster for UPS and FEDEX/UPS are the ones actually moving it??? Because that's how they WANT IT!! no one would use USPS if they didn't have some advantage..... It's all planned trust me
Jake DiClemente (1 year ago)
+FGOKURULES you have any type of proof for me? I want to believe you...but i need proof
non yobussiness (1 year ago)
WeKnowTheTruth2012 (1 year ago)
USPS in the US is my favorite I always get my package in abour 3-4 days and i live in california even if ship from florida or south carolina rarely over 5 and i also get free saturday service and it gets here by 8am instead of 10am on weekdays
Also its waaaay cheaper :)
Finder 22 (1 year ago)
all depend on where and what. Some pervious comments state that USPS is so international. what most of those people don't realize or chose to negate is that USPS hands off the package when it gets to the destination country. at that point service changes and delivery times can slip. There is only so much USPS can do with this but most of the time there are no issues. domestic packages where i live USPS always wins. they rarely damage packages and they are prompt. of course there are the occasional shipping delay. i have found out because UPS & Fedex drivers are under so much pressure to deliver they are more likely to leave door slips in areas of population density (aka lots of apartments) this is fact in Los Angeles. large international package Fedex is the clear winner. Although i personal almost always ship usps because their checkout system is hands down the fastest and best which fallows their service for the most part. just so happens they have the lowest cost.
Kev Zen (2 years ago)
USPS is the best for smaller packages less then 5 LBS. Anything above that go with a private company that is competitive and of good quality.
Kazoo4You (2 years ago)
Fed-Ex is the best with experience. UPS is absolute TRASH. and USPS can be good some times and TRASH other times. UPS has the worst customer service they have no fucking people working the phones, (they do but its a complicated process to get to them they have no direct number)
John Panera (2 years ago)
Plus considering UPS and Fedex both save costs by handing off their packages to the US Postal Service for final delivery they still aren't saving enough to pass the savings to the consumer apparently. US Postal Service all the way.
Memphis Metal Fab (2 years ago)
At my business we ship and receive many packages both to and from business and residential addresses. FED EX is by far the most dependable and cost less than UPS. UPS is a far 2nd and USPS is dead last! USPS is only used to mail out letters that are not important. WE have nothing but problem with USPS delivered packages to the point where I will no longer purchased products that will be shipped via USPS. I always pay for FED EX.
Hern Chen (2 years ago)
Noticed that UPS was holding packings (if necessary) so they don't deliver package before expected date. The USPS tracking now works (It was a joke before) and they deliver quickly and they deliver on Saturday (even saw a Sunday delivery). However, they give a wide expected delivery dates.
John Accardi (2 years ago)
USPS is soooo unreliable
Scott Z (2 years ago)
I call bullshit, usps has the worst delivery dates when they say 2 day delivery they really mean 2 weeks, and likely damaged goods upon delivery.
Teletrip (2 years ago)
That sounds more like UPS and Fed Ex. If I order something from the west coast it will DEFINITELY get to me on the easy coast in 3 days via USPS. If the package was sent via Fed ex or even worse UPS it would take a minimum of 5 days. If I wanted the package delivered faster using UPS or Fed Ex I would have to pay a substantial amount more than I do with Priority Mail via USPS.
feie7 (2 years ago)
But were any of the packages that weren't damaged over 2 pounds? I would like to know which company has the smallest rate of damages for over two pounds. I think everyone would agree that this is important, especially if someone was receiving or shipping a laptop. Also there's a lot of research on whether or not a package is especially targeted for damage or abuse once it has been marked "fragile". I think it would be great if you did another shipping test.
Marilyn Hansen (2 years ago)
It would have been nice if you also included which company has the least amount of damages for packages over 5 pounds.
Stamps.com (2 years ago)
Hi Marilyn, While we did intend to include damage statistics in this research, not one of the packages delivered encountered any type of damage. Some of the boxes had bent corners, but no contents were damaged in any of the more than 150 packages sent. Thanks! Eric, Stamps.com
Bonnie Banotah (2 years ago)
USPS is the worst when it comes to international shipping
megaleadjp (2 years ago)
Thank you. My new company learned a lot. I thought usps would be last.
Michael Rodriguez (2 years ago)
Yea I used USPS priority shipping before, it still took them almost about a week until I got my package, never using that again
jim Jimm (2 years ago)
I ordered a volume pot for my guitar from the fender store online, they used fedex ground, this order was sent last thursday 5/22/14 it has taken 6 days for it to show at a transfer station in PHOENIX, AZ from BLOOMINGTON, CA and my delivery date from fedex is still 5 days out, the weight of the package is 0.3 lbs so your telling me fedex isn't snail mail the USPS would have had it here in 2 to 3 days for a lot less money (fender charges for orders under a certain amount) , I could have rode a bicycle to Bloomington Ca. and back to Vegas faster than fedex ground ships, I mean really it's a 3 1/2 hour drive in a car, whats up fedex. This isn't the first time I've had problems with fedex being so dam slow if I had the option I would have told fender to ship it UPS or USPS.
Nizar Abboud (2 years ago)
After 4 very disturbing experiences, I cancel every purchase that is going to be delivered by Fedex. The problem with them is not only the staff are liars... i.e. they say we did not find you home when you have been waiting for delivery all day,but also that the delivery office staff are rude and aggressive. In one incident I had to go back home twice to bring in evidence that I am who I am. I would not recommend Fedex to my enemy. It is repulsive.
David Vick (2 years ago)
USPS sucks don't use it you have to pay extra for insurance. Ups and FedEx both come with insurance default
Teletrip (2 years ago)
but they are sllllloooowwwww
Call Me Witcher (3 years ago)
From my own anecdotal research and use. . . Here's my rundown of each category.
Before I get started I've used all three for 15 years. . . from shipping and delivery . . .
The below sequences are from best to worst, I've shipped over fifteen thousand packages and received twelve thousand since 1999.
These are my own figures and rough estimates. I also added a few of my own categories.
*Price:*. . . USPS, UPS, FedEx.
*Delivery speed from all preferred speeds shipped on same day on a Monday:*. . USPS, UPS, FedEx.
*Tracking/Scanning from every type of shipping type(s):*. . . UPS, FedEx, USPS. . . these pertain to accuracy in tracking/scanning, updating in real time, etc.
*Damaged Packages and Structural Integrity:*. . . USPS, FedEx then UPS. This pertains to package delays from damage, receiving the package damaged or patched up from damage.
*Customer Service:*. . . UPS, FedEx, USPS. . . I've had many problems with USPS customer service from local/municipal locations and online/phone customer service ranging from nine states. . . Wisconsin, Illinois, New Jersey, New York, Ohio, California, Florida, Texas, Oklahoma and Oregon. . . involving shipped and sent packages.
To brief USPS has been the best overall and i commend them. . . UPS however has a tenacity and a vigor that makes them unique and tied in my opinion with USPS, lastly FedEx. . . Moreover all three of these companies help each other in various ways and the pro's and con's of each are vastly different making them all acceptable given the situation. . .
None of my opinions and information is biased and comes from a genuine source.
All information was collected from my small business and own personal use of these three companies.
Cher Park (3 years ago)
what about international! USPS blows with first class and priority
Stamps.com (3 years ago)
Hi Cher, USPS has the lowest cost options for international of all carriers using First Class Package International Service (up to 4 lbs.) It's great for lower cost items. Also, they have added Delivery Confirmation to 14 countries. For higher value items, Priority Mail International and Priority Mail Express International also is good. Thanks for the comment! Eric, Stamps.com
Indu Singh (3 years ago)
I also Agree USPS shipping speed is excellent and cost is fordable. Problem is only that USPS customer service is not good.We have to wait very long to catch them. we have to wait long to talk with them. Specially In East Brunswick,NJ post office. Online claim does not work. We never got any refund when we have applied.So USPS needs to improve to their customer service. FedEx and UPS customer service is excellent.
Stamps.com (3 years ago)
Hi Indu, Thanks for the comment and glad to hear the USPS is getting your packages delivered quickly for a low cost! Eric, Stamps.com
Jason Kuehn (3 years ago)
I agree that USPS is going to be by far the lowest cost for SMALL packages. This is the sole reason I use USPS at my business. However, USPS still has some major drawbacks they need to work on if they want to compete in the big leagues. I've found that there is a much higher chance of a package getting lost with USPS while it is almost unheard of with Fexex/UPS. Second, I have to disagree with the tracking part of this video. USPS tracking may sometimes work for express packages, but it's almost useless for priority mail. The tracking info is often not even updated until long after the package is delivered. Third, if anything does go wrong, their insurance is almost totally useless. Stamps.com knows this, which is why they offer their own insurance. Finally, USPS doesn't even know the meaning of the words "user interface" or "workflow". Without stamps.com doing this work for them (and doing a good job with it), no business would ever use USPS at all.
Kevin Becker (3 years ago)
Although this is from stamps.com, who has a vested interest in USPS, my company is finding that for residential addresses, USPS is significantly less than UPS for small packages. UPS adds $2.90 to residential addresses. This is about the difference between the two. And we have had similar experience with them for delivery. And yes, many packages get delivered faster with Priority Mail over UPS Ground.
Stamps.com (3 years ago)
Thanks for the comment Kevin. You are correct in that we (Stamps.com) do have a vested interest in this study, since we print postage for the USPS. But our hope was to show large companies and small business owners who have currently do not use the USPS that they are missing out on a great option for e-commerce packages (most are under 5 lbs. and going to a residence). Companies will always have big and small packages, so a mix of carriers will probably be the best option. But we hope with USPS providing speedy delivery and the lowest costs, online retailers will have an advantage competing for the customer. Cheers! Eric, Stamps.com